NFL’s Top Defensive Tackles for 2025
As NFL training camps approach, the spotlight is on the league’s top defensive tackles for
2025. A recent survey of league executives, coaches, and scouts has produced a compelling ranking, showcasing the best in the game today. The standout conclusion is that while three players have established themselves at the top, there is a notable drop-off after them. This year’s rankings reflect a competitive landscape, with several veterans making a comeback and a few newcomers trying to assert their dominance.
Dexter Lawrence II Leads the Pack
Dexter Lawrence II of the New York Giants has emerged as the top defensive tackle for 2025, boasting a significant improvement over the past year. Lawrence’s game expanded dramatically in 2024, culminating in a nine-sack season while facing a staggering 74.5% double-team rate, the highest among interior linemen. His versatility, balance, and ability to finish plays have made him a nightmare for opposing offenses. An NFL personnel director noted, “A true three-down game wrecker who needs attention every single snap.” With his performance, Lawrence is not just a top player; he’s a game changer.
Chris Jones Maintains Elite Status
Coming in second is Chris Jones of the Kansas City Chiefs, who remains a top contender in the league. Despite a close vote split with Lawrence, Jones’s 19.9% pass rush win rate is the best among interior rushers, with 62 pass-rush wins over the last four years. While some evaluators praised his size and strength, concerns about his one-dimensional play emerged. An NFC scout stated, “He’s been the face of a championship defense for a long time and he’s next to impossible to block one-on – one.” At 31 years old, managing his usage could be key to maximizing his impact moving forward.
Jalen Carter’s Rapid Ascent
Jalen Carter of the Philadelphia Eagles, only 24, made significant strides this past season, earning All-Pro second-team honors and a Super Bowl ring. With four and a half sacks in the previous season and a notable 8.8% pass rush win rate, Carter’s disruptive playstyle has garnered attention. His potential is immense, with one veteran coach describing him as having “Hall of Fame-type ability.” However, consistency against one-on – one matchups remains an area for growth as he develops further in his career.
Jeffery Simmons Faces Challenges
Tennessee Titans’ Jeffery Simmons ranks fourth despite concerns about his production last season, where he registered only five sacks. Evaluators note his unique power but question his pass-rush explosion. An NFC executive observed, “Still dominant vs. the run – – I didn’t see the same pass-rush explosion.” The struggles of the Titans as a team may have impacted Simmons’s ability to shine, but his potential remains evident.
Quinnen Williams Continues Consistency
Quinnen Williams of the New York Jets holds the fifth spot in the rankings. He has consistently made an impact over the last three seasons, amassing 23.5 sacks, including 12 in
2022. Although questions about his run defense arose, evaluators recognize him as a complete player who demands attention from opposing offenses. His ability to influence game plans speaks to his importance in the Jets’ defensive scheme.
Leonard Williams Shines in Seattle
Leonard Williams, now with the Seattle Seahawks, has seen a resurgence in performance this season, ranking sixth. Under new coach Mike Macdonald, Williams achieved career highs in quarterback hits and tackles for loss. His versatility has been highlighted, as he continues to showcase his impressive physical attributes. A veteran coach noted, “His play finally matched his abilities last season.” This revival is a promising sign for the Seahawks’ defense.
Nnamdi Madubuike’s Mixed Performance
Nnamdi Madubuike of the Baltimore Ravens comes in seventh. After a breakout 2023 season, his metrics dipped in 2024, raising questions about his consistency. His previous success led to a significant contract extension, but the change in defensive coordinator may have affected his performance. Evaluators still recognize his potential, labeling him as a quality player with elite burst and explosion.
DeForest Buckner Remains a Force
DeForest Buckner of the Indianapolis Colts ranks eighth. Despite missing five games last season, he has averaged 8.4 sacks per season since
2018. His 16.4% pass rush win rate is impressive, showcasing his ability to disrupt offensive lines. Recognized as one of the most underrated defensive players, Buckner’s consistency keeps him in the top tier of defensive tackles.
Vita Vea’s Career Year
Vita Vea of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers ranks ninth, having slimmed down for a career-high seven sacks last season. His raw strength and ability to impact games are well-recognized, with coaches noting his importance to the defense. Vea’s dual-threat capability, including dropping into coverage, adds a unique dimension to his game.
Cameron Heyward Defies Age
Cameron Heyward of the Pittsburgh Steelers rounds out the top ten. At 36, he produced an impressive performance with eight sacks and a first-team All-Pro selection, defying expectations of decline. His ability to apply pressure consistently has kept him relevant in the league, showcasing that age does not necessarily dictate performance.
Honorable Mentions Reflect Depth
Honorable mentions include Christian Wilkins, Derrick Brown, Zach Allen, Zach Sieler, and Kobie Turner, each recognized for their potential and contributions to their teams. These players exemplify the depth and competitiveness of the defensive tackle position in the NFL today. In summary, the 2025 rankings of defensive tackles highlight a mix of established stars and emerging talent, showcasing the dynamic nature of the league. Each player’s performance metrics provide insight into their impact on the game, contributing to their teams’ defensive strategies in the upcoming season.
